top of page

The last day of COP31: still no final text as all other negotiations come to an end

29 minutes ago
5 min read

November 20th – Its Day 12 of Cop31. After two weeks, a consensus on the cover decision still seems far away. But some progress may still emerge from Antalya.


The ‘Antalya Accord’?


This morning (November 20th), countries were still in deep debate over the most recent cover decision draft, released yesterday. This is the official, main political document that comes out of a COP, a signal to the world on the progress made. Compared with the first draft, all mentions of fossil fuels had been removed from the new text, and language on other targets like electrification and adaptation finance had been weakened.

Panama’s Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro warned in a press conference that the world is “being held hostage” by the “petroleum mafia” and is threatening to block any final agreement that omits action on fossil fuels amongst other priorities:

  • Every decision must be based on the “best available science” and follow IPCC findings.

  • Text must acknowledge “failure of 1.5C” target and parties must report on what they are doing to close the gap between the current trajectory and 1.5C.

  • Move to adopting decisions by simple majority at UN climate talks, when consensus is not possible.

  • “Global oil production must be capped at current levels.”


Last night Panama sent an open letter to the COP31 Presidents saying they would refuse any decision that did not meet their demands.  As a “carbon negative” country with strong climate commitments, the Environment Minister said that Panama “will not lend its name to an outcome that continues to ignore and attempts to excuse each nation’s individual responsibility”.


Today, we have also seen a growing number of ‘developed’ countries opposing the draft. The group was led by Netherlands climate minister Stientje van Veldhoven, who represented the views of Germany, France, Denmark, Panama, Brazil, Luxembourg, Ireland, the UK, Sweden, Indonesia, Iceland, Finland, Marshall Islands, Tuvalu, Vanuatu, Portugal, Norway, Fiji and Spain. Guatemala, Belgium and Switzerland were also on the stage of the press conference. An EU representative said: “This draft cover decision is unbalanced, it is unacceptable, and it won’t fly”. A third draft of the cover decision, which is likely to be called the ‘Antalya Accord’, is expected to be released today, but perhaps not until late into this evening.

 

Week two summary


The pressure has been mounting in this second week of the conference. Last week technical negotiations faced delays, so this week delegates were working around the clock to try and come to some compromise. While high level ministerial events and pledging sessions were happening in the core COP meetings, major new reports were launched at side events.


Yesterday the International Energy Agency released their annual World Energy Outlook, which heavily focused on the energy crisis following the war in Iran. IEA Director Fatih Birol says it is the worst on record and reinstated his commitment to electrification as a response. “We have now entered the age of electrification” he said, after the report showed a 4% increase in global electricity demand.  


On day 8 the focus was science and industry, and we heard from leading climate experts on the importance of robust and up to date science. The leading expert on planetary boundaries, Johan Rockström , presented the key updates from the UN Emissions Gap report . He reaffirmed the conclusion that we are facing an inevitable overshoot of the 1.5°C target, adding that this will come in the next 3–5 years.


On climate finance, the main work has been happening inside negotiations. Major climate funds like the Green Climate Fund and the Warsaw Mechanism for Loss and Damage work in cycles. Parties need to agree on the work mandate, each fund’s key priorities and how progress will be measured each year. This year, the pressure was also on to replenish the funds, however, negotiations didn’t succeed in that objective. The Adaptation Fund received just $50 million dollars, where it needs $300 million annually to sustain its work.


This week the COP Presidency has also announced various measures on climate action. The Antalya AI Pledge announced on Monday is a voluntary framework for countries and companies to commit to making AI part of the climate solution. The 35% electrification by 2035 target has now been logged in the Global Action Agenda, alongside other new initiatives. This means that even in the face of a dismal cover agreement, some actions may be taken forward, such as funding for grid build-out and the ‘Implementation BRIDGE’  linking projects to partners.

 

An update on negotiations


Away from high-level ministerial meetings and the cover decision, there has been the slower work of technical negotiations through the two weeks. These won’t make the headlines of this COP, but they are important to national climate policies and the working of the UN framework. Technical negotiations are where text is agreed to help progress towards the main goal of the Paris Agreement.


These might be discussions on Carbon Markets (CMA8), the working of a mechanism (SBI65) or even agreeing the dates and venues for future discussions (COP31).

As an overview, this COP31 (meeting of Parties in the UNFCCC) is also the meeting of parties in the Paris Agreement (CMA8), and the Kyoto Protocol (CMP), as well as other working groups and subsidiary bodies. Each of these have their own agenda items that negotiators work through, starting with a long draft with lots of brackets and footnotes. To read an explainer of this process, see here.


Parties narrow down the options and brackets towards the end of each summit, and start to generate “clean” texts, which contain no areas of disagreement and can be converted into “draft decisions” that are ready for formal adoption at the closing plenary of the meeting. As we come to the end of this COP, there have been some agreed texts, but many remain as drafts with some even being deferred to future meetings of the subsidiary bodies, in Bonn (June) or the following COPs (November).


 


As of today: 11 have been postponed, 27 not agreed or ‘no text’ outcomes, 27 are in draft ‘text stage’, and there have been 37 agreed agenda items.

 

What can we expect next?


Tonight in Antalya the Closing Plenary will formally pass everything agreed during the negotiations. However, the cover decision, which will be the main outcome once complete, is delayed until at least Saturday morning. Negotiations may carry on far into the weekend, as different countries and groups form new alliances: countries with fewer resources may not be able to stay as negotiations overrun, so they need to ensure that their priorities are not lost in the last amendments by allying with countries able to stay over the weekend and represent their interests in their absence.  As a result we have already seen some new groups forming, like the UK and the EU aligning with island states Tuvalu, Vanuatu and Fiji on reinstatement of fossil fuels in the decision.

 

The COP31 Presidency still have a way to go until a final consensus can be reached.

 

Climate Action for Associations (CAFA) has been virtually attending COP31 in Antalya as official NGO Observers. We are committed to delivering an end of COP report next week to ensure you stay fully informed on the outcomes that matter to membership organisations and their members.

 

Learn more about CAFA and how you can join here.


Comments


bottom of page