top of page

Halfway through COP31: the state of negotiations

8 hours ago
6 min read

Negotiations ran late into Saturday night on Day 6 at COP31. At the end of the first week, we would expect to see near-finalised drafts of many of the agenda items, as well as items from the working groups for the Paris Agreement and the Kyoto principal.


However, as we enter week 2, many of these decisions have been delayed as countries struggle to cooperate and leave negotiations to be forwarded to this week.


The UN climate talks run under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), a 1992 treaty with nearly 200 parties. Decisions are made by consensus, so a single objecting country can hold up an outcome.


Here, we explain how decisions are made at COP, to help make clear what we can expect over the coming days.

 

The ‘architecture’ of the UNFCCC


The UNFCCC is constantly evolving to better aid climate action. At major conferences, such as at Paris, new bodies are set up to work towards specific targets.


Three decision-making bodies meet side by side. Firstly, the Conference of the Parties (COP), the Convention’s top body. Secondly, the CMA, for countries in the Paris Agreement and finally the CMP, for the older Kyoto Protocol. That is why, for example, COP31 and CMA 8 are the same event.



Two technical bodies prepare the grounds for negotiations at each Conference. These are the Subsidiary Body for Scientific and Technological Advice (SBSTA) and the Subsidiary Body for Implementation (SBI). They meet in Bonn each June and in the first week of each COP. They don’t make decisions, but they adopt conclusions, which may forward into draft texts to be used in the next week. Expert committees, such as the Adaptation Committee, report into this system.


Negotiations work item by item. Each goes to informal consultations led by co-facilitators, who gather views and redraft the text. Countries mostly speak through blocs such as the African Group, the Alliance of Small Island States, the least developed countries, the EU and the Arab Group. Text stays unagreed until everyone accepts it. When time runs out, it can be forwarded to the next body, or return on the next session’s agenda.


The first week is mainly technical and involves many intricate debates over wording and raises ‘red lines’ – points that countries will not accept in any form. In the second week, ministers and the COP presidency take over, working to close the remaining gaps before the final plenary on the last day. Most items end in their own decisions, but the presidency also drafts an overarching cover decision, which sets the political message of the whole COP. See the Mutirão decision from last year here as an example. It often carries the issues that need a political deal, and it is usually the last piece to be settled and the most contested. Unfinished technical items do not fall into this, they return into the schedule of technical talks the following June.


Agenda-item decisions at COP31

 

Many of the discussions happening this week are likely to carry on next week as they remain unresolved. Simon Evans, from CarbonBrief, put together a status review of each of the main negotiation tracks, currently gridlocked.


Simon Evans writes “Gridlock is par for the course midway through the COP, but several observers told Carbon Brief that this year is worse than usual” which seems like the reasonable conclusion to take away when we look for settled items, mostly absent at this point. Subsidiary bodies, at this point should have settled their items, and COP and CMA items should be mostly drafted for the technical part for ministers to pick up in Week 2.


However, many unresolved issues are being handed over from subsidiary bodies to the main overarching bodies of the conference (COP, CMA, CMP), drafts are heavily bracketed, timeframes are not agreed, conclusions are procedural only. “With so much to resolve in the next week, it is perhaps no surprise that the Australian presidency is avoiding any predictions on when COP31 will come to an end.”


1)       Mitigation


Mitigation had a limited presence on the Day 6 agenda, where discussions mainly focused on the Mitigation Work Programme (MWP). The EU stressed the urgency to address the overshoot of 1.5°C and to enhance the Programme, although the text discussed received pushback from other Parties on the basis that it was going beyond the Programme’s mandate. Discussions stalled and are handed over to Week 2 — although a previous version of the text will make it to next week’s negotiations.


On technology, carbon capture and removals are a point of tension, with the Arab Group signifying interest in the technologies. Other mitigation items included the role of oceans, which Parties wish to integrate into UNFCCC processes and workstreams. Finally on mitigation, another discussion item on Day 6 was the Just Transition Work Programme, with no agreement but at least a basis for negotiation in the shape of a note from Day 5. Most mitigation avenues (e.g. electrification) were discussed in previous days.

 

2)       Adaptation


Adaptation talks closed their first week without agreements on the two biggest items, which have both been forwarded into the second week. On National Adaptation Plans (NAPS), countries set out their views on a revised draft and many delegations said they were disappointed that no more time was available. The co-facilitators proposed conclusions forwarding the text to the next session of the Subsidiary Body for Implementation (SBI 66) in June. Grupo Sur, supported by the UK and the Environmental Integrity Group (EIG), argued for continuing the discussions in the second week instead. The SBI agreed to forward the matter to COP31, so the COP presidency can now choose whether to take it up. The draft carries a warning that it does not represent agreed views, but it does have one agreed point: reporting should separate finance for preparing plans from finance for implementing them.


On the Global Goal on Adaptation (GGA), parties considered a new version of the draft text. With limited time, the co-facilitators suggested forwarding the discussions to the latest text to the Conference of the parties to the Paris Agreement, which means discussions will continue next week if this is agreed. Smaller items were concluded on issues like adaptation communications and on matters relating to the least developed countries. Draft decisions on the Warsaw International Mechanism on Loss and Damage were adopted by the COP and CMA so they will follow negotiations into the next week.


3)       Climate finance


Climate finance talks ended the first week without a deal on either of the two funds they covered. Both go into the second week as draft texts.


The Adaptation Fund pays for projects that help vulnerable countries cope with climate impacts, mostly through grants. It was created under an older climate treaty, the Kyoto Protocol, and countries are now moving it to serve the Paris Agreement alone. The main area of disagreement is who will control it in its new place under the Paris Agreement. African countries want its own board, not the UN secretariat, to make key decisions. The EU and Norway want to change how wealthy countries’ board seats are described, saying the old wording doesn’t fit a Paris sub-body. African countries asked whether that would weaken the expectation that those countries also give money. Least developed countries called the Fund a vital source of grants and praised its board.


The Green Climate Fund is the UN’s main fund for helping developing countries cut emissions and adapt. Countries are drafting guidance for it, and the biggest disagreement is who should pay. Some want wealthy countries to provide and increase finance, while others want developing countries to contribute voluntarily. The Arab Group called widening the donor base a “red line”, meaning they won’t accept it. The Philippines said loans are the wrong tool for adaptation, and the EU backed grants for the poorest and most vulnerable countries.

 

4)      Measuring progress


Progress monitoring covers how the world tracks what countries are doing on climate. The first week ended with one clear disagreement and several routine decisions.


In negotiations, there was a clear disagreement over the GHG Data Interface, an online tool meant to bring countries’ emissions data together in one place. SBSTA Chair Adonia Ayebare told the closing plenary that parties could not agree. Under the draft rules of procedure, the item then returns automatically to the next technical session, in this case the next SSBTA meeting in June 2027. The Arab Group and Russia said technical work had added features beyond what countries had approved. The EU, the Umbrella Group and Pacific small island states replied that a clear mandate was adopted at an earlier session (SB 62) and cannot be reopened.


The SBSTA adopted conclusions on research and systematic observation, the monitoring of the climate system that feeds the science. Chile praised their quality for addressing gaps and recognising advances, and the EIG and Umbrella Group stressed decisions based on the best available science.


Several decisions were made about helping developing countries to report their emissions and progress. Conclusions were adopted on financial and technical support for reporting under the Convention, which assists countries with their reports. The matching item on support for reporting and review under the Paris Agreement was forwarded to CMA 8, so it goes to the second week.


 

Observers at COP31 described the end of the first week as a half-time stocktake, with delegates rushing to tidy text and widespread disappointment at the lack of progress.

 

Climate Action for Associations continues its daily coverage today.

 

To learn more about CAFA and how to join, see here

Comments


bottom of page